Main Content

The Great Brooklyn and Manhattan Exodus: Why families are moving to Staten Island in 2026

More families are looking beyond Manhattan and Brooklyn, and Staten Island has become one of their top destinations. We’re seeing buyers prioritize space, privacy, and family-friendly neighborhoods without giving up the advantages of living in New York City. Instead of settling for smaller homes, many are choosing properties with backyards, additional living space, and access to parks and well-regarded schools.

It’s one of the reasons moving to Staten Island has become such a popular choice in 2026. This growing demand also creates new opportunities for local homeowners considering a sale. 

Whether you’re relocating or preparing to list your property on Staten Island, understanding today’s market can help you make the most of your next move.

👉Relocating to Staten Island? Contact us for a smooth, stress-free move!

WHY ARE FAMILIES MOVING TO STATEN ISLAND IN 2026?

Families are moving to Staten Island to get more space, a suburban feel, and affordable housing while staying connected to Manhattan and Brooklyn.

The trend has been steadily growing over the past few years and is expected to continue through 2026. Staten Island was the first choice for 12% of Brooklyn homebuyers who moved to other boroughs. Rising home prices and changing lifestyle priorities have encouraged many families to explore neighborhoods they might not have considered before.

Reasons families are moving to Staten Island:

1. More home for your money 

Families are moving to Staten Island due to housing affordability.

Compared to Brooklyn and Manhattan, buyers can find larger homes, more bedrooms, private driveways, finished basements, and spacious backyards – all without leaving New York City.

Staten Island’s median listing price is around $700,000. While that’s still a sizable investment, it’s much more accessible than many neighborhoods in Brooklyn or Manhattan.

Families also appreciate that Staten Island offers a variety of properties. You’ll find everything from detached single-family homes to semi-attached properties, as well as condominiums in select neighborhoods.

Architectural styles vary widely, including Colonials, Cape Cods, raised ranches, and split-level homes, giving buyers plenty of options to match their lifestyle and budget.

For many buyers, a larger home means more than just extra square footage. It provides room for a growing family, changing routines, and the flexibility to stay in one home longer.

👉 Browse hundreds of homes for sale on Staten Island to find your dream property today!

2. A neighborhood feel that’s hard to find elsewhere

You might wonder, “Is Staten Island suburban?“

The answer is yes compared to the rest of New York City.

While Staten Island is one of NYC’s five boroughs, many neighborhoods feature tree-lined streets, detached homes, parks, playgrounds, and quiet residential areas. Children play outside, neighbors greet each other, and families stay in the same neighborhood for years.

That said, you still have easy access to city amenities. Restaurants, shopping, recreational facilities, healthcare, and community events are all nearby.

For those coming from high-rise apartments or crowded neighborhoods, living on Staten Island offers a peaceful change of pace while still being close to everything city life has to offer.

👉 Search top family homes for sale on Staten Island

3. Schools and family-friendly communities matter

Many parents buy homes not just because they need a place to raise their children, but because they want to provide them with a sense of security.

Staten Island has earned a reputation for family-focused neighborhoods, active community involvement, youth sports, and access to well-regarded schools.

Many residential areas also feature parks, waterfronts, walking trails, and recreational spaces that encourage outdoor family fun.

The factors listed above often come up when people ask us if Staten Island is a good place to live. While every family has its own priorities, Staten Island’s combination of space, community, and convenience makes it a great place to live.

👉 Browse affordable homes for sale on Staten Island

4. Commuting is easier than you think

A common misconception is that moving to Staten Island means giving up easy access to Manhattan. In fact, many commuters still travel to the city every day.

The Staten Island Ferry runs 24/7 a day at no cost, connecting St. George to Lower Manhattan in about 25 minutes. Depending on where you live, you can also use the Staten Island Railway, buses, or drive across the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge when needed.

While some families choose to own a car because of the suburban feel, many find the commute more manageable than they initially expected.

👉 Ask us about Staten Island properties with a 25-minute Manhattan commute

WHAT ARE THE BEST NEIGHBORHOODS FOR FAMILIES MOVING TO STATEN ISLAND?

The best neighborhoods for families on Staten Island vary by region, offering a distinct balance of historic charm, outdoor space, or commuter convenience. 

⛵ GREAT KILLS (South Shore) – For outdoor recreation & beach access

Great Kills remains a beloved spot for families on Staten Island. Residents enjoy nearby parks, waterfront activities, a marina, and charming detached homes on spacious lots. It’s a fantastic choice for those seeking established neighborhoods with a strong sense of community. 👉 Contact us today! Ask us about homes for sale in Great Kills

🏡 WESTERLEIGH (Mid-Island) – For historic charm & community spirit

Westerleigh, located in the Mid-Island area, offers classic Staten Island charm along with easy access to shopping, schools, and major roads. Family-friendly residential streets attract families seeking a central location without losing the neighborhood charm. 👉 Contact us today! Ask us about homes for sale in Westerleigh

⚓ TOTTENVILLE (South Shore) – For small town peace & large backyards

Tottenville, on Staten Island’s southern tip, features some of the borough’s largest homes on generous lots. Many buyers looking for quiet surroundings and a suburban vibe find Tottenville an ideal destination. 👉 Contact us today! Ask us about homes for sale in Tottenville 

🍃 ANNADALE (South Shore) – For tranquil streets & nature preserves

Annadale blends quiet, low-traffic streets with direct access to protected parklands and nature centers. It is ideal for families wanting peaceful, green surroundings near schools and trains. 👉 Contact us today! Ask us about homes for sale in Annadale 

🚢 ST. GEORGE (North Shore) – For walkability & fast Manhattan commutes

St. George is perfect for professionals commuting into Manhattan, thanks to the Staten Island Ferry Terminal. The neighborhood also offers excellent restaurants, cultural attractions, historic homes, and new condos. 👉 Contact us today! Ask us about homes for sale in St. George 

Staten Island Ferry on the dock

The Staten Island Ferry connects residents to Lower Manhattan while offering one of New York City’s most recognizable waterfront views.


FAQs

Is it hard to adjust to life on Staten Island after living in Manhattan or Brooklyn?

Many families relocating to Staten Island from Manhattan or Brooklyn find the transition easier than they expected. Although routines change, most quickly notice the benefits: more living space, quieter neighborhoods, and plenty of outdoor areas while still being part of New York City.

Is it easy to buy a home on Staten Island in 2026?

It is relatively easy to buy a home on Staten Island in 2026 due to higher housing turnover rates providing consistent inventory, though success requires navigating local pricing dynamics and choosing neighborhoods that match your specific transit needs.

Do I need a car on Staten Island?

Not necessarily, but many find having a car on Staten Island helpful. Depending on your neighborhood, a car can make running errands and getting around a lot easier. However, public transportation options include buses, the Staten Island Railway, and the Staten Island Ferry. 

HOMES R US REALTY IS YOUR STATEN ISLAND LOCAL EXPERT

Whether you’re planning a move from Brooklyn or Manhattan or considering selling your Staten Island home, local guidance can make the process much smoother.

At Homes R Us Realty, we’ve proudly served Staten Island homeowners and buyers since 2000. For over 15 years, we’ve been one of the borough’s top real estate teams, understanding each neighborhood, the current market, and what families want in their next home.

If you’re thinking about moving to Staten Island, we’d love to help you find the perfect neighborhood for your lifestyle. And if you’re selling, we’ll make sure your home stands out to motivated buyers eager to make Staten Island their new address.

Call 718.668.2550 or email us to learn how we can help you buy your dream home or sell your current one.

Recent Posts